There's a progression when making amigurumi. For the beginner (and always, always for toys for children under the age of 3) sewn eyes are the perfect eyes for an amigurumi.
The next stage is safety eyes from Joann Fabrics or a similar store. They're big, they're expensive, there's not much variety, but at least they're snap-in safety eyes. For those who aren't familiar with them, these are the kind of eyes used in most commercial plush toys.
When you find yourself wanting more variety in your amigurumi eyes, or something a little different, where do you turn? How do you source safety eyes other than the standard brown and black?
I was lucky when I started out, the lovely andricongirl was nice enough to clue me in to CRs Crafts, which sells wholesale and bulk safety eyes. I was going out of my mind trying to locate enough safety eyes to fill orders. I order from them every few months or so, and they're my main source for standard black 6mm safety eyes since I can purchase them by the 50pr. They have fantastic customer service and ship relatively quickly.
I'm not the only one who orders from CRs. Occasionally, I find that they're backordered, which is when I turn to 6060.etsy.com for my immediate black safety eye fix. I was impressed with 6060's fast service, accurately priced shipping, and free animal nose included with the order (admittedly, I'm a sucker for freebies). 6060 also offers the opportunity to purchase mixed color packages and hand painted eyes.
An aside, here. I've been attempting to make my own hand-painted eyes recently and haven't been terribly impressed with the results. I'm not sure what the major eye retailers are doing differently and can't vouch for it. The colors on the etsy listings are impressive.
For wildly colored safety eyes and good prices, especially for a unique project, I find myself looking to trulyoutrageous. She has a variety of safety eyes that I haven't seen before, and am itching to get my hands on and use. Trulyoutrageous also has the advantage of being a fellow crocheter, and in fact she sells crochet patterns in her etsy shop. I rather like her crochet patterns from the pictures, although I haven't tried them. (ETA: As of this writing, she is on vacation, check out her shop when she comes back). She also has an incredible etsy shop selling cupcake liners and accessories--it's pretty cool, you can check her blog to get the link.
I hope this gives you some alternatives and some help when it comes to your search for plastic safety eyes! Just remember:
- Safety eyes are only safe for children over the age of three.
- CRS crafts carries bulk safety eyes in a limited range of colors
- 6060 has variety as well as noses and other snap on parts
- Trulyoutrageous carries multicolored safety eyes in various sizes
- Enjoy your amigurumi!